The election silver lining playbook

All the silver linings to the election that hasn't actually finished yet

The election silver lining playbook
Photo by Aakanksha Panwar / Unsplash

I’m not sure about this one. Just know that Emily asked me to write it, so if you don’t like it, it’s probably her fault. “Could you do a piece on the election outcome?” she asked, in a paraphrased way.

“I don’t know if people would like it,” I said, probably. “I tend to be a bit… overly pragmatic. But in an unlikeable, blunt way.”

Feel free to skip to the comments if you read this already in your email!

Skip to comments

“That’s why I want you to write it,” she said, approximately. “Because all I can feel about the election is sadness and despair and you seem… kind of OK?”

This is kind of correct. What tends to happen with me is that I spend the time before any given Event freaking out, but once the Event actually arrives I’m almost chipper. “This is fine,” I say, my face falling off like the This Is Fine dog. Anyone who’s ever done a play and has spent the preceding hour spewing their guts out only to experience a kind of ethereal calm once they take the stage will know exactly what I mean.

This meme is almost ready for high school, if you want to feel even older than you already do.

Before you read, a word of warning. These are not your well-researched data-driven evidence-based conclusions. Other people might have written those; I wouldn't know, because I am busy writing this. These are Takes, which means "take them with a grain of salt."

One thing that is true, at the time of writing, is that the election is not actually over. The special votes are still being counted, and if previous elections are any guide, there is still a chance that they flip key seats and/or add a an MP or two to the left-bloc total. If enough of this flipping and MP-adding happens, then the Opportunity party will decide who the Government will be. Which brings me to my first point:

The Left might finally stop ballbagging Opportunity

New Zealand political opinion polls were remarkably consistent this election (as they tend to be) and one thing they showed quite early on was that there was no path to power for the Left bloc without the Opportunity party. The Left being what it is, we promptly welcomed our new necessary allies by shitting all over them. Opportunity derangement reached startling heights during the election campaign with breathless "reporting" from people who are absolutely not journalists that party leader Qiulae Wong's mum once worked for a right-wing political party. Now we're in the electoral interregnum waiting for the Specials, people are hand-wringing that they might "betray" the left by "going with the Coalition." Of course this will stop instantly if Opportunity join the Left, but I still have two remaining takes: 1. It's not a "betrayal" to potentially do the thing that your party was founded to do. 2. Opportunity as kingmaker is - I don't want to exaggerate this, so I will choose my words carefully - infinity times infinitely better than Winston Peters as kingmaker. Even in a right-wing coalition. Yes, I too would vastly prefer a left-led coalition, but if denying Winston Peters the opportunity to be politically consequential in what will - God and the implacable laws of thermodynamics willing - be his last turn in Parliament is the only thing Opportunity achieves, it's a hell of a consolation prize.

Hipkins will probably go and Labour might remember people elect politicians to do things

Labour leader Chris Hipkins spent three years promising nothing. As the election drew nearer, perhaps reasoning that nothing motivated voters like a big zero, he doubled down on nothing. He undertook an onanistic orgy of rulings-out and publicised his not-to-do lists. Labour, it seemed, would rather read from the Keir Starmer "don't be the Conservatives and become utterly despised after election because you're jailing pensioners who oppose genocide" playbook than the Mamdani "promise useful things and become beloved after election because you actually deliver" playbook. "You ain't seen nothing yet" wasn't Labour's election slogan, but it should have been. The good bad news is that we might still get Mr Nothing as Prime Minister. The bad good news is that if the Coalition get back in, Hipkins will have twice failed to do his only actual job, which is to lead Labour to forming a Labour-led coalition. You would think that Labour would tire of this, and sack him, but who knows - perhaps Hipkins will hang on, with the powerful argument that he promised nothing and, unquestionably, delivered.

In addition to much else, the Simpsons also predicted Labour’s electoral strategy

National had one of their worst-ever results and lost some of their best (worst) people

National, captained by a cross between a haemorrhoid and one of those weird thumb aliens from Doctor Who, got absolutely wrecked, not by Labour but by their own sheer unlikeable incompetence, with the result that some of the people the political media likes to call "top talent" and I call "cynical grifting apparatchiks" lost their jobs. Bye Chris Bishop! May you vanish into smoky obscurity, your manifest destiny to become Prime Minister thwarted by a sentient pimple. Bye Nicola Willis! May your political career remain as cancelled as those ferries. Bye Paul Goldsmith! Perhaps one day you will write another book, and this one will be titled “Hoisted! My Own Petard.” Bye Gerry Brownlee! You are no longer Speaker, and the silence is golden. Of course, these people will immediately be given plum directorships as well as lobbyist and media roles, which in many countries would be illegal but isn't here because ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. However, I will take that over having Nicola Willis and her curdled-milk grin as Finance Minister. These and other MPs will be replaced by a crop of no-name weirdos from hick electorates where a bloated corpse could win election if it was blue enough. It has the potential to be very, very funny. Of course it's disastrous if they end up in charge but at least we can have some good humour on our way to the gallows.

A Sontaran from Dr Who
Luxon as the election results rolled in

The Greens got their best-ever result

Despite either being somewhere left of Stalin (if you are still on Twitter for some reason) or offering a kind of sensible enviro-Keynesian policy that would have been table stakes in the 1960s (if you actually read their policies) the Green Party got its best ever result, which will likely become better still when the special votes come in. Was it the result of having likeable, charismatic leaders who energised and expanded their base with promises to actually do things, or would the Greens have done better still had they followed the Labour playbook and promised no hope and no change? I guess we'll never know!

One note I’d like to chuck in here is that it isn’t actually the Greens’ fault that the left didn’t/has not yet won. Like every other political tragic I had a good moan on main on election night that Green candidates seemed to be eating Labour candidates winning margins in key electorates. But this is not the candidates’ fault. They are doing their best to spread the good word about their party and be popular. That’s part of their job. The fault is with a.) the architects of MMP, for wrongly assuming that electorates wouldn’t matter much in the future and so they could use un-proportional First Past the Post to elect candidates and b.) successive governments, including Labour, for not fixing these known glitches in MMP before they became game-breaking bugs and c.) the parties of the left, for not doing what the Right has done for decades (see: Epsom) and coming to strategic non-compete agreements in key electorates to give leftist candidates the best possible shot of winning. So if Labour stans could kindly stop sending death threats to Green candidates, eh?

Leftists are going to remember that they need to win as well as be right

I don't actually think this will happen but I'd love to be wrong! You see, every leftist knows that the Left would be great if their own personal flavour of leftism were the one that everyone else followed, and I am no different. Therefore I can confidently proclaim that the problem with the Left is that they care more about being right (not that kind of right) than winning.

Evidence for this is unfortunately everywhere, from the debasement of Marxism from a living revolutionary philosophy for workers into academic gobbledegook, to the fact that the overwhelming majority of online lefties seem to think that quote-posting your political opponents is a great idea and that if we all did that a bit more everyone would see how stupid and bad the Right is and how great... whatever it is the Left stands for is. Let me say it once more with even more weariness than I said it last time: the Right loves it when you dunk on them, because every irrecoverable second of your precious life that you spend doing that is one more second that you are not advocating for the political values that you presumably believe in and which - the Right knows perfectly well - are actually overwhelmingly popular once you cut through the propaganda. Far better to tangle you up in actually spreading the propaganda. If leftists could just resist that toxic urge, great things could happen. For instance, the Left’s unlikely win in Brazil was carved out by leftists assiduously spreading their own message and memes on online platforms while avoiding giving a platform to the right. If only New Zealand’s online left could do the same.

No matter what happens with the special votes, if the left wants to win next time, it needs to remember the lesson from this apocryphal snippet someone posted on Reddit the other day:

John Key said they ran internal polls every six weeks during his government and over 90% of respondents couldn't name more than two people in government or anything the government had done. A huge chunk of the electorate vote based on vibes and believing catch phrases.
You may not like it, but it’s stupid politics

This is the big truth of politics, here and abroad: a truly surprising number of people either hate (or profess not to care) about politics but are simultaneously swayable into voting for whoever vibes. This may seem stupid to politics-knowers. It isn’t! Not following politics is a sanity-preservation strategy. Have you seen politics? Nor are these voters cruel, necessarily. While there are an unsettlingly decent-sized proportion of voters who are just fine with cruelty, as long as it happens to those Other People, the answer to the riddle of “how could they have voted for the Coalition given everything terrible they’ve done,” is that those voters simply didn’t know. How could they? The Government certainly didn’t tell them. Nor did Labour. Much of the media excused and sanewashed and bothsided, as it so often does. Here’s something uncomfortable to sit with, like a hedgehog cushion: if many voters didn’t know and should have known about the coalition’s myriad cruelties, who should have told them? The answer is us. I know we all tried, and some of us tried to the point of breaking and beyond, but perhaps we are not trying in the right ways, or the right places.

Here is where horrible centrists and Very Savvy politics-knowers swing in with arguments about how the only way to win is for the left to be more right, and to that we can simply gesture at the rising tide of fascism swamping Left-in-name-only governments in Britain and Australia. If people ever wanted Third Way milquetoast neoliberal-but-nice, they don't want it now.

Fortunately, overseas examples also make it clear what people do want: to be able to afford food and a decent place to live, to have meaningful work, to have thriving healthcare and school systems, to feel like their country is making progress on useful things like not having its shit kicked in by a new extreme weather event every other week. We also know, most recently from the US, that voters will happily elect a remarkable diversity of candidates for public office - you might even say a rainbow of candidates - if they show empathy for voters and an inclination to help them with their lives.

And this is the Left's great strength. Only the Left can be right (as in correct) and deliver meaningful - or even necessary - societal progress. The chief reason I am a leftist is that it is practically the only politics to have an even partly coherent position on climate change, starting with the admission that it exists. But, crucially, it is also the only politics that can make a meaningful, positive difference to the overwhelming majority of people. That should be a slam-dunk, and it could be, if the Left realised that it must win first and be right after.